The coulda shoulda type
Like "Oh, it was slight too tight, come on, I would've piped
But our schedules contradicted we're always tied down"
Ay pipe down, the first night ya boy layed the pipe down
A lot of dudes had a chance to have sex with this girl before him, but never did. So they made up excuses, e.g. Bad scheduling, always tied down. Joey, on the other hand, fucked on the first night. Which would explain the baseball (Foul ball) reference earlier in the song.
To help improve the meaning of these lyrics, visit "Pennyroyal" by Joey BADA$$ Lyrics and leave a comment on the lyrics box