Whole thing played out like magic and it’s kinda weird
It's like I did a trick and you won't reappear

from Joey BADA$$ – Pennyroyal Lyrics on Rap Genius

Meaning

In typical magic tricks, the magician will make things appear. e.g. A rabbit in a hat. Apparently Joey isn’t a good magician, because his girl isn’t coming back.

He could also be saying that he fucked another “trick” so now she wont come back to him

To help improve the meaning of these lyrics, visit “Pennyroyal” by Joey BADA$$ Lyrics and leave a comment on the lyrics box