This can be both a contradiction or a reaffirmation of the previous line. Both lines imply Jay’s music is up to a certain standard.
The question is can he meet both standards without that being a contradiction in itself. If the Halal and Kosher codes serve the same function, to determine what is acceptable and permitted by [god’s] law, then there is no contradiction.

We at RapGenius have decided that it is obligatory of Jay Elecyarmulke to shout out the Jewish religion frequently in his music

A sexual reference to the Scarecrow in the Wizard of Oz, where he meets Dorothy and talks about his only fear is “a lighted match.” However, later on, he says:

But I’d face a whole box full of them for the chance of getting some brains.

Bear in mind that “getting [a] brain” refers to the foreplay to which he refers in the previous line, which is also associated with “the box.”

The phrase of Exodus origins, referring to something very sweet and appealing. Israel is described as “the land of milk and honey.”

In Islam, Allah gives the believers rivers of honey, milk and wine in heaven.

Fun fact: honey is the only product made from an unkosher animal (bees) that is itself kosher.

That would possibly either be Jay’s baby momma Erykah Badu or Kate Rothschilds (likely the former)

A reference to the 2Pac line which has since been used countless times in hip-hop

Referring to the streets in Fayetteville, like Lewis Street, where he grew up with killers who he didn’t know were killers

A play on the common American idiom to stay on one’s toes, meaning to stay alert. Girls stay alert and on the lookout for Cole

You put Dr. Scholls inserts in your shoes to comfort your foot and your toes

Remember that promise about these two dropping a joint album? If only…

As MLK was being tempted in the club, his wife, Coretta Scott King was in the back of his mind, maybe keeping him from cheating

Cole has previously referenced Coretta in his music