"I father, I Brooklyn Dodger them / I jack, I rob, I sin /..." (Jay-Z – Brooklyn (Go Hard)) | rejected

Robinson dodged the “penant”? I.e., he never won one? I don’t get it.

"Abbreviate him / His past is her fav, his stats is amaze ..." (Nicki Minaj – Blazin) | accepted

“abbreviate him” = “abbreviate Kanye”. E.g.: ‘Ye

"Green ice, red light. Caution: Gucci rock yellow" (Gucci Mane – Lemonade) | accepted

So.. quadruple entendre or what?

"This is an aristocracy / I’m Socrates, but my skin more c..." (Kanye West – See Me Now) | accepted

Is Kanye also saying that, like Socrates, he is a “social gadfly”? This jibes with the previous line about killing the hypocrisy (which, was a huge Socrates meme)!

"You gotta pardon Jay, for selling out the Garden in a day" (Jay-Z – Dirt Off Your Shoulder) | accepted

are you sure the line isn’t:

“you got a pardon, Jay, for selling out the Garden in a day”

i.e., spoken by a third party?

"52 cards come out when I'm through dealing / Now 52 bars ..." (Jay-Z – Dirt Off Your Shoulder) | accepted

There’s a card dealer / drug dealer situation going on here!!!

"[Verse 3: Scarface]" (Jay-Z – This Can't Be Life) | accepted

In “Decoded” Jay explains that Scarface was actually in the recording studio when he got the news. Supposedly he spit the verse minutes after

"My chain heavy, yeah, yeah, my chain heavy / My chain hea..." (Kanye West – Chain Heavy) | accepted

Isn’t this also a reference to the Gucci Mane song? http://rapgenius.com/lyrics/Gucci-mane/Heavy

"Bob's killer" (Jay-Z – Lucifer) | accepted

In Decoded he says this line is about Bigg’s brother Bobalob (who was shot while driving)

"Living spree" (Kanye West – Good Life) | accepted

Also a play on “killing spree”?