- In the Wee Small Hours of the Morning prod. by David Foster
- I Only Have Eyes for You prod. by Bergen White & Jim McKell
- I Prefer the Moonlight prod. by Brown Bannister
- I Remember You prod. by David Foster
- Islands in the Stream by Kenny Rogers & Dolly Parton prod. by Albhy Galuten, Barry Gibb & Karl Richardson
- Islands in the Stream (Live) by Kenny Rogers & Dolly Parton prod. by Don Was, Keith Wortman, Ken Levitan & Robert Rauffer
- I Swear prod. by Bergen White & Jim McKell
- It Had to Be You prod. by Bergen White & Jim McKell
- I Trust You prod. by Brent Maher & Jim McKell
- It's a Beautiful Life prod. by Joe Chemay & John Guess
- It’s Gonna Be Easy Now prod. by Kyle Lehning & Warren Hartman
- It's the Messiah prod. by Brent Maher & Jim McKell
- It Turns Me Inside Out
- I’ve Got A Lot To Learn
- I Want a Son
- I Want to Make You Smile prod. by Larry Butler