- I Don't Want to Hear It by Firefall
- I'd Really Love to See You Tonight by England Dan & John Ford Coley
- I'd Surrender All by Randy Travis
- If I Didn't Have You by Randy Travis
- If I Don't Fall Tonight by Anne Murray
- If It Ain't One Thing It's Another by Randy Travis
- If You Can’t Be Good, Be Good at It by Neal McCoy
- If You Only Knew by Randy Travis
- If You Only Knew by Firefall prod. by Howard Albert & Ron Albert
- I Know You by Neal McCoy
- I'll Be Your Eyes by Anne Murray
- I'll Fly Away by Kenny Rogers (Ft. The Whites) prod. by Warren Hartman
- I'll Fly Away by Randy Travis
- I'll Just Pretend by Mandy Barnett prod. by Bill Schnee
- I'm Always On A Mountain (When I Fall) by Randy Travis
- I’m Gonna Have a Little Talk with Jesus by Randy Travis (Ft. Take 6)
- I’m Losing Your Love by Anne Murray
- I'm Movin' On by Randy Travis
- I'm Not Supposed To Love You Anymore by Bryan White prod. by Billy Joe Walker Jr.
- I'm Ready by Randy Travis