- I Can't Let Go Now by Lee Ryan prod. by Ash Howes & Martin Harrington
- If That's What It Takes prod. by Lenny Waronker & Ted Templeman
- If You Wanted to Hurt Me prod. by Shannon Forrest
- I Got Lost Tonight by Tim Moore prod. by Michael James Jackson
- I Gotta Try prod. by Lenny Waronker & Ted Templeman
- I Gotta Try by Kenny Loggins prod. by Bruce Botnick & Kenny Loggins
- I Got the News by Steely Dan prod. by Gary Katz
- (I Hang) On Your Every Word prod. by Ted Templeman
- I Heard It Through the Grapevine prod. by Simon Climie
- I Just Can't Let Go by David Pack prod. by David Pack & Michael Verdick
- I Just Can't Let Go by Patti Austin prod. by David Pack
- I Keep Forgettin' (Every Time You're Near) prod. by Lenny Waronker & Ted Templeman
- I Keep Forgettin' (Every Time You're Near) by Local Natives prod. by Chris Sorem
- I Keep Forgetting by Patti LaBelle prod. by Babyface, Daryl Simmons & Gregg Pagani
- I Knew You Were Waiting (For Me) prod. by Simon Climie
- I'll Be Home for Christmas
- I'll Be Over You by Toto prod. by Toto
- (I'll Be Your) Angel prod. by Ted Templeman
- I'll Never Give Up by Amy Holland
- I'll Wait by Van Halen prod. by Ted Templeman