- I Don’t Want to Go On Without You by Nazareth prod. by Manny Charlton
- I Don't Want To Go On Without You by The Drifters prod. by Jerry Wexler
- I Feel Good All Over by The Drifters prod. by Mike Leander
- If I Didn't Have a Dime by Gene Pitney prod. by Aaron Schroeder & Wally Gold
- If I Would Marry You by Tammi Terrell
- If I Would Marry You (Stereo Version) by Tammi Terrell
- If You Don't Come Back by The Drifters prod. by Mike Leander & Mike Stoller
- If You Need Me by Solomon Burke
- If You Need Me by Wilson Pickett
- I Gave My Love a Diamond by Them
- I Got to Go Back by Teddy Robin & The Playboys prod. by Norman Cheng
- I Got to Go Back (And Watch That Little Girl Dance) by The McCoys prod. by Jeff Barry
- I'll Come Running by Lulu
- I'll Come Running Over by Samantha Fish prod. by Bobby Harlow
- I'll Take You Where the Music's Playing by The Drifters prod. by Jerry Wexler
- I'm Hanging Up My Heart for You by Solomon Burke prod. by Jerry Wexler
- I Need You by Precious Wilson prod. by Frank Farian