- Nightmare Time 2 Theme, Pt. 1 by Original StarKid Cast of Nightmare Time 2 (Ft. Angela Giarratana, Bryce Charles, Corey Dorris, Curt Mega, Jae Hughes, Jaime Lyn Beatty, James Tolbert, Jeff Blim, Joey Richter, Jon Matteson, Kim Whalen, Lauren Lopez & Mariah Rose Faith) prod. by Matt Dahan
- Nightmare Time 2 Theme, Pt. 2 by Original StarKid Cast of Nightmare Time 2 (Ft. Angela Giarratana, Bryce Charles, Corey Dorris, Curt Mega, Jae Hughes, James Tolbert, Jamie Lyn Beatty, Jeff Blim, Joey Richter, Jon Matteson, Kim Whalen, Lauren Lopez & Mariah Rose Faith) prod. by Matt Dahan
- Nightmare Time 2 Theme, Pt. 3 by Team StarKid (Ft. Angela Giarratana, Bryce Charles, Corey Dorris, Curt Mega, Jae Hughes, Jaime Lyn Beatty, James Tolbert, Jeff Blim, Joey Richter, Jon Matteson, Kim Whalen, Lauren Lopez & Mariah Rose Faith) prod. by Matt Dahan
- Nightmare Time 2 Theme, Pt. 4 by Team StarKid (Ft. Angela Giarratana, Bryce Charles, Corey Dorris, Curt Mega, Jae Hughes, Jaime Lyn Beatty, James Tolbert, Jeff Blim, Joey Richter, Jon Matteson, Kim Whalen, Lauren Lopez & Mariah Rose Faith) prod. by Matt Dahan
- Nightmare Time Theme by Team StarKid (Ft. Angela Giarratana, Corey Dorris, Curt Mega, Jaime Lyn Beatty, James Tolbert, Jeff Blim, Joey Richter, Jon Matteson, Kim Whalen, Lauren Lopez, Mariah Rose Faith & Robert Manion) prod. by Team StarKid
- No Easy Way
- No Pressure
- Not Alone/Goin' Back to Hogwarts (Reprise) by Team StarKid (Ft. Bonnie Gruesen, Darren Criss, Jaime Lyn Beatty, Joey Richter, Joseph Walker & Lauren Lopez) prod. by StarKid Productions
- Nothing Better (feat. Britney Coleman)
- Nothing To Do Here But Live
- Not Over Yet by Team StarKid (Ft. Corey Dorris, Joe Moses, Joseph Walker & Tyler Brunsman)
- On the Threshold of Eternity by Starry Musical (Ft. Joe Viba & Mariah Rose Faith) prod. by Kelly D'Angelo and Matt Dahan
- Our Doors Are Open by Team StarKid (Ft. Angela Giarratana, Corey Dorris, Curt Mega, Jaime Lyn Beatty, James Tolbert, Jeff Blim, Joey Richter, Jon Matteson, Kim Whalen, Lauren Lopez & Robert Manion) prod. by StarKid Productions
- Priceless by Team StarKid (Ft. Ali Gordon, Brian Holden, Brian Rosenthal, Clark Baxtresser, James Tolbert, Jamie Burns, Joey Richter, Lauren Lopez & Original StarKid Cast of A VHS Christmas Carol) prod. by Brian Holden & Corey Lubowich
- Ready to Go by Jaime Lyn Beatty (Ft. Brian Holden, Joey Richter, Joseph Walker, Lauren Lopez & Meredith Stepien) prod. by StarKid Productions & Team StarKid
- Robin Sucks! by Team StarKid (Ft. Denise Donovan, Jim Povolo, Julia Albain, Lauren Lopez, Meredith Stepien, Nicholas Joseph Strauss-Matathia & Nico Ager) prod. by StarKid Productions
- Rogues Medley (Live) by Team StarKid (Ft. Brian Holden, Jaime Lyn Beatty, Joey Richter, Joseph Walker, Lauren Lopez & Meredith Stepien) prod. by StarKid Productions
- Rules of the Road by Marty Scanlon (Ft. Kelly Parker & Lauren Lopez)
- Sami/Harry (Live) by Team StarKid (Ft. Jaime Lyn Beatty) prod. by StarKid Productions
- Sands Of Time/Golden Rule by Team StarKid (Ft. Jaime Lyn Beatty, Lauren Lopez, Nick Gage & Robert Manion)