- I’d Die for You by Margo Price prod. by Sturgill Simpson
- If You Run by The Desert Sessions prod. by Josh Homme
- I Gave You by Matt Sweeney & Bonnie "Prince" Billy prod. by Bonnie "Prince" Billy & Paul Oldham
- I'll Make You Mine by Joanna Sternberg
- Indigo Blue by Jake Bugg prod. by David "Fergie" Ferguson
- In Heaven by The Armed (Ft. Julien Baker)
- In the Event of My Demise by Jake Bugg prod. by David "Fergie" Ferguson
- In the Sky Over the City by Whipping Girl prod. by Isobel Morris
- I Told You I Couldn't Stop by Jakob Dylan prod. by Rick Rubin
- I've Got Me by Joanna Sternberg
- I Will Be With You by Joanna Sternberg
- Jesus, I / Mary Star of the Sea by Zwan prod. by Billy Corgan & Bjorn Thorsrud
- Leaden Crow by Whipping Girl prod. by Isobel Morris
- Leonard by Bonnie "Prince" Billy
- Letting Me Down by Margo Price prod. by Sturgill Simpson
- Lift Us Up by Matt Sweeney & Bonnie "Prince" Billy prod. by Bonnie "Prince" Billy & Paul Oldham
- Lorelie-Marie by Anna Ternheim
- Lorena by Del McCoury