- I Can't Do That Anymore prod. by Scott Hendricks
- If I'm Not In Love prod. by Byron Gallimore
- If I'm Not In Love With You (Unreleased)
- If I Should Fall Behind prod. by Bryan Gallimore
- If My Heart Had Wings prod. by Byron Gallimore
- If My Heart Had Wings (Single Mix) (Unreleased)
- If This Is the End prod. by Byron Gallimore
- If You Ask prod. by Byron Gallimore
- If You're Gonna Fly Away prod. by Byron Gallimore
- I Got My Baby prod. by Byron Gallimore
- I Love You prod. by Byron Gallimore
- I Need You by Tim McGraw prod. by Byron Gallimore, Darran Smith & Tim McGraw
- Inilah Hidupku by Morris Davista prod. by Dhika Aljauhari & Morris Davista
- I Think I Will prod. by Dann Huff
- It Matters to Me prod. by Scott Hendricks
- It's Your Love by Tim McGraw & Faith Hill prod. by Byron Gallimore, James Stroud & Tim McGraw
- It Will Be Me prod. by Byron Gallimore
- I've Got This Friend (Ft. Larry Stewart) prod. by Scott Hendricks
- I Want You prod. by Dann Huff
- I Would Be Stronger Than That prod. by Scott Hendricks