- I'm Your Puppet by Yo La Tengo prod. by Yo La Tengo
- Into Fall by Dump
- Invisible by Dump
- Ira searches for the slide, sort of (Friday) by Yo La Tengo prod. by Georgia Hubley & Ira Kaplan
- I Should Have Known Better by Yo La Tengo prod. by Roger Moutenot
- Isolation Tank by Yo La Tengo prod. by Yo La Tengo
- Is That Enough by Yo La Tengo prod. by John McEntire
- It Takes a Lot to Laugh, It Takes a Train to Cry by Yo La Tengo prod. by Georgia Hubley & Ira Kaplan
- I Wanna Be Your Lover by Yo La Tengo prod. by Roger Moutenot
- I Was the Fool Beside You for Too Long by Yo La Tengo prod. by Fred Brockman & Roger Moutenot
- I Wish/You Wish by Dump
- James and Ira demonstrate mysticism and some confusion holds (Monday) by Yo La Tengo prod. by Georgia Hubley & Ira Kaplan
- James gets up and watches mourning birds with Abraham (Wednesday) by Yo La Tengo prod. by Georgia Hubley & Ira Kaplan
- Jury Duty by Dump
- Just For You by Dump (Ft. Georgia Hubley)
- Last Days of Disco by Yo La Tengo prod. by Roger Moutenot
- Leaving Home by Yo La Tengo prod. by Yo La Tengo
- Leaving Home (Alternate Version) by Yo La Tengo prod. by Yo La Tengo
- Let's Be Still by Yo La Tengo prod. by Roger Moutenot
- Let's Do It Wrong by Yo La Tengo prod. by Yo La Tengo