- I Wanna Be Ignored by Ezra Furman & The Harpoons
- I Was Zero by Sage Francis
- I Will Ask You Twice by Ryley Walker prod. by Leroy Bach & Ryley Walker
- Jezebel by Iron & Wine
- Joëlle by Young Man in a Hurry
- John Appleseed's Lament by Counting Crows
- Joy by Iron & Wine
- Kingdom of the Animals by Iron & Wine
- Larkin by Young Man in a Hurry
- Laundry and Jetlag by Fenne Lily prod. by Fenne Lily
- Lazy Eye by Fruit Bats
- Lean Into the Light by Iron & Wine
- Le Ballet D'or by Counting Crows prod. by Gil Norton
- Let It In by Sam Roberts Band
- Lies (of November) by Foreign Diplomats
- Life Like Weeds by Modest Mouse
- Lillian, Egypt by Josh Ritter
- Lily's Nice Shoes! by Foreign Diplomats
- Little Houdini by Sage Francis