Puppy eyes when I go, sayin’ “stay with me”
Aw, girl, you bad as hell and yet I’d love to
He’s talking about a second girl now who he slept with. When he leaves after sex she pleads for him to not leave but he says that even though the girl is hot and he wants to stay; he must go because he’s committed to another girl who he actually likes (the first girl from earlier in the verse). This is shown in the following line as he says he is “really makin' love” to the first girl not just fucking her like the second girl.
To help improve the meaning of these lyrics, visit "Stay (2009)" by J. Cole Lyrics and leave a comment on the lyrics box