I wanna contrast this to something. Because I could spend some time simply complaining that this is just a speech with a beat slapped on it (which it is) but the thing is, Kanye’s a talented sampler, and he’s actually done this exact tactic before to great return. So, before I talk about it, I wanna play another flip Kanye did, Who Will Survive In America:
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=HzNnXH7e9jc&user=UCRY5dYsbIN5TylSbd7gVnZg
That was originally called Comment #1, a proto-rap poem by Gill-Scott Heron about what he felt to be a tension between bourgeoisie white liberals and poor black nationalists. The only instrumental accompaniment it had was a pair of drums he banged on. Kanye added layers of instrumentation, making it sonically bigger than it originally was, and by selectively sampling, he was able to turn it into something prophetic. It feels like a poetic death to blind American nationalism, as the entire country wakes up and realizes not only are they fucked, but it might be too late to turn back. It’s… fucking beautiful.
Now I want you to contrast that with this mess:
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=JGMm8u9t8tM&user=UCRY5dYsbIN5TylSbd7gVnZg
First off: Fuck your Christian propaganda. Second off: Fuck you for thinking you have the sanctimony to spew Christian propaganda at me. Third: This is lazy. My God, that little MIDI keyboard bounce? That’s all you could muster? DJ Mustard has made better beats than that. DJ Mustard scored a hit song with Rihanna with a better beat than that. This song gets to be this high on the list not just because it’s bad (which it is), or that’s sickening to hear propaganda (it is), but because empirically, Kanye has a better skill set than this. The guy can work, the guy can sample, the guy can hold coherent thoughts. But this is an example of what too much stress does to you (that and endorsing a fucking fascist). Fuck off, ‘Ye.